Dr. J. Frank Yates

Thinker
clear glass light bulb on sand during daytime

Difficult Decisions Done Right

Intro

Dr. J. Frank Yates was a professor, lecturer, researcher, diversity advocate, and pioneer of decision-making science. Yates’ decision management research made him one of the first academics in the field of decision science to apply multidisciplinary discoveries to important decisions in the real world. An author of over 100 scientific publications, Yates’ contributions to the field are far-reaching and immense.

Yates was a pioneer in forwarding diversity in academia, as he established some of the first institutions designed to aid marginalized scholars. For his brilliant mind, commitment to the social good, and his desire to apply decision science to the hardest problems, Dr. J. Frank Yates is a manifestation of everything we strive for at The Decision Lab.

Decision theory is very rarely wrong about a decision, but it’s often silent on difficult questions.


- Dr. J. Frank Yates

On their shoulders

For millennia, great thinkers and scholars have been working to understand the quirks of the human mind. Today, we’re privileged to put their insights to work, helping organizations to reduce bias and create better outcomes.

Find Out How

Key Quotes

“The goal of decision evaluation is not to blame or punish. It is to determine precisely where and why the decision-making process broke down in order to reduce the odds that mistakes will be repeated. It is to make us better and our companies stronger.”

- Dr. J. Frank Yates

 

“If we are always making inaccurate judgments, why aren’t we dead already?”

- Dr. J. Frank Yates

 

“No company committee would sign off on a major decision just because a member says, “I don’t know why, but that just feels like the right thing to do. So let’s just do it, OK?” But many managers will confess to times when they would like to do exactly that: pursue some action on the basis of vague intuitions.”

- Dr. J. Frank Yates

 

“Let me be the Devil's advocate … if not the Devil himself!”

- Dr. J. Frank Yates

 

“Good and bad things don’t “just happen” in or to a business. They happen in large measure because of actions that particular people in the company take or fail to take. And why do people pursue the actions they do? Because of their own decisions or those made by others” 

-  Dr. J. Frank Yates

Historical Biography

Jacques Frank Yates was born in Memphis, Tennessee on September 1st, 1945. An outstanding student, Yates graduated maxima cum laude with an A.B. degree from Notre Dame. In 1967, he moved to Ann Arbour to pursue a master’s degree in mathematical and computational psychology at the University of Michigan. After getting his master’s, he continued his career at the University of Michigan as both a faculty lecturer and Ph.D. student

At the time, Black academics like Yates were highly unrepresented, an issue Yates fought to resolve. While completing his Ph.D., Yates was instrumental in establishing institutions for African-American academics. His main accomplishments as a graduate student include establishing the Comprehensive Studies Program, a program which aids Black students achieve academic success, and laying the groundwork for the Department of Afroamerican and African Studies at Michigan.

After achieving his Ph.D, Yates became a full-time professor at University of Michigan, where he would spend 50 years working as a researcher and professor, unraveling mysteries of the decision-making process.

Yates’ research was both groundbreaking and diverse. He primarily studied the cognitive process of decision-making, how we make good decisions, and how culture affects decision-making capacities. Yates also examined how we can overcome cognitive biases that prevent us from making good decisions, such as uncertainty avoidance, decision neglect, and overconfidence. As a professor of both marketing and psychology, he worked hard to make his findings accessible for as many individuals as possible. His “Cardinal Issue Perspective”, led to important insights in the fields of marketing, management, and healthcare.

Yates’ commitment to diversity did not stop in graduate school. As a professor, he established the Ross School's Preparation Initiative, a program designed to assist undergraduate students from economically distressed or underrepresented racial groups in entering the bachelor of business program. After a long career of commitment to diversity, Yates was awarded the Harold R. Johnson Diversity Service award. Unfortunately, Yates passed away last year. However, his efforts promoting diversity and insights into the decision-making process benefit our world to this day.

Cardinal Perspective of Decision Making

Yates found that difficult decisions typically follow a particular, step-by-step process. If we fail in any of these steps, we make the wrong decision or fail to make one altogether. As a business professor, Yates focused mainly on management, however, his decision-making system can be utilized for big, tough decisions in our day-to-day lives. He dubbed this system the “Cardinal Issue Perspective”, which is composed of ten decision issues:

  1. Need: 
    The first step is deciding if a decision should be made. In a company, this usually occurs when problems or opportunities present themselves. Entering this stage requires keeping a close eye on the competitive business landscape and acquiring foresight into the ever-shifting demands of the market. Once an opportunity or problem is found, the manager can decide whether to initiate a decision-making process or not.
  2. Mode
    The second step is to decide who should make the decision once the problem is identified. This step involves deciding to take on the opportunity yourself, delegate it, form committees, or contract external consultants.
  3. Investment: 
    The next step involves determining trade-offs and potential rewards. Think of this step as a cost-benefit analysis of a potential decision. It is necessary to decide how many resources you are willing to invest to see a decision through. These investments are both material (money, time, workers) and immaterial (stress, conflicts, and uncertainty).
  4. Options
    In this cardinal rule, we assemble possible responses to our problem or opportunity. Ideally, we will gather choices in a manner that will reveal the best solution in the least wasteful way. Yates suggests methods like asking staff, seeking aid from a consultant, brainstorming groups, or looking at past successes of other organizations in a similar situation.
  5. Possibilities 
    Here, we examine what the potential outcomes could be if we follow a particular decision. Being able to forecast effectively allows managers to avoid failure when bad fortune falls upon them, as they will have considered the adverse outcomes in their strategic decision plan.
  6. Judgment
    Closely tied to the previous step, this cardinal rule requires us to isolate the most plausible results from making a decision. Yates states this step is very important, as decisions are based on predictions, opinions, and projections. When a manager can increase the number of perspectives on the feasibility of a prediction, the quality of these judgments improves.
  7. Value 
    This cardinal rule introduces other actors into the equation: stakeholders. By pursuing a decision, we must take into consideration how stakeholders value an action and its outcomes. By assessing how they may react, we can begin to predict if key stakeholders in this process will support or oppose this decision.
  8. Trade Offs: 
    a more formal analysis of strengths and weaknesses. Yates suggests using “tradeoff techniques”, such as the MAUT technique, to accurately assess the other costs and benefits of a decision.
  9. Acceptability 
    Going back to stakeholders, we must make sure that they agree with the decision that we are about to make, as well as trust that they believe in the procedure that came up with the decision. You must look for groups that might have a problem with the decision, and determine how to work around that.
  10. Implementation
    The final step is to implement the decision, but also prevent circumstances that may cause the decision to fail. Yates outlines some of these circumstances, which range from failing to provide proper incentives for workers to failing to adequately supply resources to an initiative.

Books by J. Frank Yates

Decision Management: How to Assure Better Decisions in Your Company: Yates’ magnum opus, Decision Management, outlines Yates’ “Cardinal Issue Perspective” to describe how to make correct decisions and why our decisions often fail. This landmark book argues how powerful managing our decisions can be in our lives and businesses.

Judgement and Decision Making: Yates’ 1990 work was an early textbook on decision-making science. As this field was still in its infancy, Yates’ book was designed to be an introductory text, giving a broad overview of the science, and its developments, in a manner that would be consumable by upper-level undergraduates.

Research Directions of Black Psychologists: In 1980, Yates co-authored this book to provide key psychological insights into issues that affect the black community. The book largely focused on motivation, cognitive development, life-span development, and cultural differences. Furthermore, it addressed incorrect assumptions about the psychological functioning of black people which had been propagated previously. 

Academic Papers by J. Frank Yates: 

If you are interested in Yates’ academic work, here is a small, yet diverse sample, which shows the variety of research interests Yates worked on. Topics range from ensuring decision-making quality to the effects of culture on decision-making.

Lectures by J. Frank Yates: 

Implementation Science 2012 Keynote Address:

If you are interested in hearing Yates’ explain how his decision-making framework can help us make better medical decisions, check out his keynote address at the Michigan Institute for Clinical & Health Research. View Part 1, Part 2, and Part 3 of the lecture here.

Sources

Yates, J. F. (n.d.). Decision Management: A Game Plan to Achieve Organizational Grand Slams. Michigan Ross. https://www.bus.umich.edu/FacultyResearch/Research/DecisionManagement.html.

Schaffer, E. (2011, November 2). J. Frank Yates and a Decision-Making Theory for the Real World. Association for Psychological Science - APS. https://www.psychologicalscience.org/observer/j-frank-yates-and-a-decision-making-theory-for-the-real-world.

Legacy. (2020, November 19). Jacques Frank Yates. Obituaries. https://obits.mlive.com/obituaries/annarbor/obituary.aspx?n=jacques-frank-yates&pid=197175690.

U-M LSA Department of Psychology. (n.d.). Faculty Memorial - J. Frank Yates (1945-2020) . In Memoriam. https://lsa.umich.edu/psych/news-events/all-news/faculty-news/faculty-memorial---j--frank-yates--1945-2020-.html.

About the Authors

Dan Pilat's portrait

Dan Pilat

Dan is a Co-Founder and Managing Director at The Decision Lab. He is a bestselling author of Intention - a book he wrote with Wiley on the mindful application of behavioral science in organizations. Dan has a background in organizational decision making, with a BComm in Decision & Information Systems from McGill University. He has worked on enterprise-level behavioral architecture at TD Securities and BMO Capital Markets, where he advised management on the implementation of systems processing billions of dollars per week. Driven by an appetite for the latest in technology, Dan created a course on business intelligence and lectured at McGill University, and has applied behavioral science to topics such as augmented and virtual reality.

Sekoul Krastev's portrait

Dr. Sekoul Krastev

Sekoul is a Co-Founder and Managing Director at The Decision Lab. He is a bestselling author of Intention - a book he wrote with Wiley on the mindful application of behavioral science in organizations. A decision scientist with a PhD in Decision Neuroscience from McGill University, Sekoul's work has been featured in peer-reviewed journals and has been presented at conferences around the world. Sekoul previously advised management on innovation and engagement strategy at The Boston Consulting Group as well as on online media strategy at Google. He has a deep interest in the applications of behavioral science to new technology and has published on these topics in places such as the Huffington Post and Strategy & Business.

Notes illustration

Eager to learn about how behavioral science can help your organization?